The Judi Bari Bombing Verdict Details

Verdict Details (posted 6/19/02)

4TH AMENDMENT CLAIMS

Found to have violated Judi Bari's rights in connection with her arrest
Frank Doyle (FBI), John Reikes (FBI), and Clyde M. Sims (OPD)
Could a reasonable officer have believed that his conduct was lawful?
Doyle No; Reikes Yes; Sims NO (If yes they are immune from suit)
What amount do you award Bari to compensate for injury, loss or harm $235,000
Percentage of above damages
Doyle 10% Sims 90%
Found to have violated Judi Bari's rights in connection with May 25, 1990 search
Doyle, Reikes, Sims, Robert Chenault (OPD), Michael Sitterud (OPD)
Could a reasonable officer have believed that his conduct was lawful?
Doyle No; Reikes Yes; Sims Yes; Chenault No; Sitterud Yes
Damages $190,000
Percentages Doyle 70% Chenault 30%
Found to have violated Darryl Cherney's rights in connection with his arrest
All UndecidedCould a reasonable officer have believed that his conduct was lawful?
Chenault Yes; All others Undecided
Found to have violated Darryl Cherney's rights in connection with May 25, 1990 search
Doyle, Reikes, Sims, ChenaultCould a reasonable officer have believed that his conduct was lawful?
Doyle No; Reikes Yes; Sims Yes; Chenault No
Damages $50,000
Percentage
Doyle 70%; Chenault 30%

FIRST AMENDMENT CLAIMS

Found to have violated Judi Bari's first amendment rights
Doyle, Reikes, Philip Sena (FBI), Sims
Damages $1,175,000
Percentages Doyle 22.5%; Reikes 22.5%; Sena 5%; Sims 50%
Found to have violated Darryl Cherney's first amendment rights
Doyle, Reikes, Sena, Sims, Sitterud
Damages $800,000
Percentages Doyle 17.5%; Reikes 17.5%; Sena 5%; Sims 50%; Sitterud 10%

CONSPIRACY CLAIMS

For conspiracy to violate Judi Bari and Darryl Cherney's First Amendment rights
All not liable

PUNITIVE DAMAGES

Fourth Amendment Claims (Judi Bari)
Doyle (FBI) $300,000
Fourth Amendment Claims (Darryl Cherney)
Doyle (FBI) $100,000
First Amendment Claims (Judi Bari) $1,000,000
Reikes (FBI) $600,000; Sims (OPD) $400,000
First Amendment Claims (Darryl Cherney)  $550,000
Reikes (FBI) $300,000; Sims (OPD) $250,000

Summary of Damage Awards  (Posted in response to media inquiries, revised 6/19/02)

Total damages $4,400,000

1st Amendment $3,525,000 (80.1%), 4th Amendment $875,000 (19.9%)
FBI defendants $2,399,000 (54.5%), OPD defendants $2,001,000 (45.5%)
Compensatory $2,450,000 (55.7%), Punitive $1,950,000 (44.3%)
Judi Bari $2,900,000 (65.9%), Darryl Cherney $1,500,000 (34.1%)

Punitive damages $1,950,000

FBI defendants $1,300,000 (66.7%), Oakland defendants $650,000 (33.3%)

Click here for a spreadsheet table of the damages giving more detail and summing up damages by plaintiff, defendant, violation, agency, and punitive vs. compensatory

The
Judi
Bari Web Site

www.judibari.org

---

Tables of Damages Awarded in Bari vs. FBI on June 11,
2002  (Posted in response to media inquiries)

Damages by Plaintiff and Claim
Plaintiff / Claim	Judi Bari	Darryl Cherney	Totals
Compensatory Damages
False Arrest (4th Amendment)	$235,000	N/A	235,000
Unlawful Search (4th Amendment)	190,000	50,000	240,000
Free Speech Violation (1st Amendment)	1,175,000	800,000	1,975,000
Compensatory damages subtotal	1,600,000	850,000	2,450,000
Punitive Damages
4th Amendment Violations	300,000	100,000	400,000
1st Amendment Violations	1,000,000	550,000	1,550,000
Punitive damages subtotal	1,300,000	650,000	1,950,000
Totals	2,900,000	1,500,000	$4,400,000
Total 1st Amendment damages $3,525,000 or 80% of total damages

Damages by Defendant and Organization
Damages /Defendant	Reikes FBI	Doyle FBI	Sena FBI	Sims OPD	Chenault OPD	Sitterud OPD	Total
Compensatory	$404,375	595,000	98,750	1,199,000	72,000	80,000	2,450,000
Punitive	900,000	400,000	0	650,000	0	0	1,950,000
Total	1,304,375	995,875	98,750	1,849,000	72,000	80,000	$4,400,000
FBI defendants total   $2,399,000				OPD defendants total   $2,001,000

 

---

To be placed on the U.S. Mail list for updates on Judi Bari's
lawsuit against the FBI, or to make a tax deductible contribution to help
fund the lawsuit, please contact:

REDWOOD SUMMER JUSTICE PROJECT

P.O. Box 14720, Santa Rosa, CA 95402

Phone (707) 887-0262 or FAX (707) 887-0865

Email RJF at judibari.org

• If you have comments or suggestions for the Judi Bari Web Site, send
  email to webmaster at judibari.org
• For email news and updates about the  Judi Bari case send email
  to BariNews-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
• Return to top of this page
• Return to Judi
  Bari Home Page www.judibari.org

Read More

Officer Richard "Dick" Grossman

Read More

Officer Dexter

Read More

Lieutenant Edwards

Read More

Officer Steve Rohwer

Read More

Sergeant David Rangel

Read More

Lieutenant Steve Bertolozzi

Read More

Captain Steve Skinner

Sorry Steve you should have spent 3,000 on that guitar

Read More

Southern Pacific Pipeline Partners and ENRON

Read More

FBI Agent Frank Doyle, Jr. and the Centennial Olympic Park bombing

Centennial Olympic Park bombing

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to navigationJump to search

Centennial Olympic Park Bombing
Part of Terrorism in the United States
Bomb fragment mark on Olympic Park sculpture
Location	Atlanta, Georgia, United States
Coordinates	33°45′38″N 84°23′33″WCoordinates: 33°45′38″N 84°23′33″W
Date	July 27, 1996 1:20 am (UTC-4)
Target	Centennial Olympic Park
Attack type	Bombing
Weapons	Pipe bomb
Deaths	2 (1 from heart attack)
Non-fatal injuries	111
Perpetrators	Eric Rudolph Army of God
Motive	[Data unknown/missing.]

The Centennial Olympic Park bombing was a domestic terrorist pipe bombing attack on the Centennial Olympic Park in Atlanta, Georgia, on July 27 during the 1996 Summer Olympics. The blast directly killed 1 person and injured 111 others; another person later died of a heart attack. It was the first of four bombings committed by Eric Rudolph.^[1] Security guard Richard Jewell discovered the bomb before detonation and cleared most of the spectators out of the park. Rudolph, a carpenter and handyman, had detonated three pipe bombs inside a U.S. military ALICE Pack. Motivated by what he considered to be the government's sanctioning of "abortion on demand", Rudolph wanted to force the cancellation of the Olympics.

After the bombings, Jewell was temporarily investigated as a suspect by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the news media falsely focused on him aggressively as the presumed culprit. However, in October 1996, Jewell was exonerated when the FBI declared that he was no longer a person of interest. Following three more bombings in 1997, Rudolph was identified by the FBI as the suspect. In 2003, Rudolph was arrested and tried before being convicted two years later. Rudolph was sentenced to life imprisonment without parole for his crimes.

Contents

• 1Bombing
  • 1.1Victims
• 2Reaction
• 3Aftermath
  • 3.1Richard Jewell falsely implicated
  • 3.2Conviction of Eric Robert Rudolph
• 4See also
• 5References
• 6External links

Bombing[edit]

Centennial Olympic Park was designed as the "town square" of the Olympics, and thousands of spectators had gathered for a late concert by the band Jack Mack and the Heart Attack. Sometime after midnight, Rudolph planted a green U.S. military ALICE pack (field pack) containing three pipe bombs surrounded by three-inch-long (7.6 cm) masonry nails, which caused most of the human injuries, underneath a bench near the base of a concert sound tower.^[2] He then left the area.

The pack had a directed charge and could have done more damage but it was slightly moved at some point.^[3] It used a steel plate as a directional device.^[4] Investigators would later tie the Sandy Springs and Otherside bombs together with this first device because all were propelled by nitroglycerin dynamite, used an alarm clock and Rubbermaid containers, and contained steel plates.^[5]

FBI Agent David (Woody) Johnson received notice that a call to 911 was placed about 18 minutes before the bomb detonated warning that a bomb would go off at the park within 30 minutes by "a white male with an indistinguishable American accent".^[6]

Security guard Richard Jewell discovered the bag underneath a bench and alerted Georgia Bureau of Investigation officers.^[7] Tom Davis of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, called in a bomb ordnance squad which included members of the ATF and FBI to investigate the suspicious bag, that was leaning against the 40-ft NBC sound tower.^[6] Jewell and other security guards began clearing the immediate area so that a bomb squadcould investigate the suspicious package. The bomb detonated two to three minutes into the evacuation, before all spectators could leave the area.^[6]

The sound of the explosion was recorded by a news crew from the German public television network ARD, who were interviewing American swimmer Janet Evans at a nearby hotel.^[8][9]

Victims[edit]

Alice Hawthorne, 44, of Albany, Georgia, was killed in the explosion when a nail from the bomb penetrated her skull.^[7] A Turkish cameraman of Turkish Radio and Television Corporation, Melih Uzunyol, 40, had a fatal heart attack while running to the scene.^[10] The bomb wounded 111 others.

Reaction[edit]

As the park reopened following the bombing.

President Bill Clinton denounced the explosion as an "evil act of terror" and vowed to do everything possible to track down and punish those responsible.^[11]

Despite the event, officials and athletes agreed that the games should continue as planned.

Aftermath[edit]

Richard Jewell falsely implicated[edit]

Main article: Richard Jewell

Though Richard Jewell was hailed as a hero for his role in discovering the bomb and moving spectators to safety, news organizations later reported that Jewell was considered a potential suspect in the bombing, four days afterward, and shortly after a brief, mistaken detainment of two juvenile persons of interest at the Kensington MARTA station. Jewell, at the time, was unknown to authorities, and a lone wolf profile made sense to FBI investigators after being contacted by his former employer at Piedmont College.

Jewell was named as a person of interest, although he was never arrested. Jewell's home was searched and his background exhaustively investigated and he became the subject of intense media interest and surveillance, including a media siege of his home.^[3]

After Jewell was exonerated, he initiated defamation lawsuits against NBC News, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, and other media entities, and insisted on a formal apology from them. Jewell's lawsuit accused Piedmont College President Raymond Cleere of falsely describing Jewell as a "badge-wearing zealot" who "would write epic police reports for minor infractions".^[12] The cases were later settled after 15 years of litigation with the Georgia Court of Appeals decision in July 2012, that the newspapers accurately reported that Jewell was the key suspect in the bombing, and emphasized he was only a suspect and the potential issues in the law enforcement case against him.^[13]

Conviction of Eric Robert Rudolph[edit]

Main article: Eric Robert Rudolph

After Jewell was cleared, the FBI admitted it had no other suspects, and the investigation made little progress until early 1997, when two more bombings took place at an abortion clinic and a lesbian nightclub, both in the Atlanta area. Similarities in the bomb design allowed investigators to conclude that this was the work of the same perpetrator. One more bombing of an abortion clinic, this time in Birmingham, Alabama, which killed a policeman working as a security guard and seriously injured nurse Emily Lyons, gave the FBI crucial clues including a partial license plate.

The plate and other clues led the FBI to identify Eric Robert Rudolph as a suspect. Rudolph eluded capture and became a fugitive; officials believed he had disappeared into the rugged southern Appalachian Mountains, familiar from his youth. On May 5, 1998, the FBI named him as one of its ten most wanted fugitives and offered a $1,000,000 reward for information leading directly to his arrest. On October 14, 1998, the Department of Justice formally named Rudolph as its suspect in all four bombings.

After more than five years on the run, Rudolph was arrested on May 31, 2003, in Murphy, North Carolina, by a rookie police officer, Jeffrey Scott Postell of the Murphy Police Department behind a Save-A-Lot store at about 4 a.m.; Postell, on routine patrol, had originally suspected a burglary in progress.^[14]

On April 8, 2005, the government announced Rudolph would plead guilty to all four bombings, including the Centennial Olympic Park attack.

Rudolph is serving four life terms without the possibility of parole at ADX Florence supermax prison in Florence, Colorado.

Rudolph's justification for the bombings according to his April 13, 2005 statement, was political:^[15]

In the summer of 1996, the world converged upon Atlanta for the Olympic Games. Under the protection and auspices of the regime in Washington millions of people came to celebrate the ideals of global socialism. Multinational corporations spent billions of dollars, and Washington organized an army of security to protect these best of all games. Even though the conception and purpose of the so-called Olympic movement is to promote the values of global socialism, as perfectly expressed in the song Imagine by John Lennon, which was the theme of the 1996 Games even though the purpose of the Olympics is to promote these ideals, the purpose of the attack on July 27 was to confound, anger and embarrass the Washington government in the eyes of the world for its abominable sanctioning of abortion on demand.

The plan was to force the cancellation of the Games, or at least create a state of insecurity to empty the streets around the venues and thereby eat into the vast amounts of money invested.

On August 22, 2005, Rudolph, who had previously received a life sentence for the Alabama bombing, was sentenced to three concurrent terms of life imprisonment without parole for the Georgia incidents. Rudolph read a statement at his sentencing in which he apologized to the victims and families only of the Centennial Park bombing, reiterating that he was angry at the government and hoped the Olympics would be canceled. At his sentencing, fourteen other victims or relatives gave statements, including the widower of Alice Hawthorne.

As reported in an April 8, 2013, Alabama blog,^[16] in February 2013, LuLu.com published Rudolph's book, Between the Lines of Drift: The Memoirs of a Militant, and in April 2013 the U.S. Attorney General seized his $200 royalty to help pay off the $1 million that Rudolph owes in restitution to the state of Alabama.

Read More